A boutique title agency,
built for Florida.

A firm started by closers, for closers.

Title Company Agency LLC was founded in Naples in 2021 by senior closers who had spent the previous two decades inside larger Florida title operations — and who’d watched the work get faster, the files heavier, and the attention thinner.

We started the firm to bring back the standard we’d been taught: one file, one coordinator, every detail. No call centers. No first-touch closers. No deal big enough that we don’t pick up the phone the day after.

Within a year we opened the Coral Gables office to cover the Atlantic coast. Today we serve every Florida county, with the same people answering the same numbers.

Underwritten by First American.

Every policy we issue is underwritten by First American Title Insurance Company — a Fortune 500 underwriter with reserves measured in the billions. When you buy an owner’s or lender’s policy through our office, the paper behind it is some of the strongest in the industry.

Florida title insurance rates are promulgated, which means the premium is the same wherever you buy it. What changes is the agent who issues it — how thoroughly they read the record, how aggressively they cure clouds, how willing they are to push back on a contract that’s sloppy on its face. That part is ours.

The numbers we keep score with.

We don’t measure ourselves on volume. We measure on three things: on-time close rate, post-closing claim rate, and how often clients open a second file with us.

Our on-time close rate runs at 100%. Our post-closing claim rate runs at zero. And roughly seven of every ten files we close come from someone we’ve closed for before, or someone they referred. We think those three numbers describe a title agency better than anything we could write here.